Matthew Lillard gained impressive horror movie notoriety playing Stu Macher in the first Scream movie. Lillard's performance as one of the first Ghostfaces was phenomenal, able to quickly switch between lovable goofball and terrifying killer. Il y a 23 heures · RELATED: Who Does Matthew Lillard Play In The Five Nights At Freddy’s Movie? Lillard should be a very familiar face to any genre fan, as he’s known for playing one of the killers, Stu Macher.