John Travolta's Allegedly Gay Penis: A History After decades of rumored gay bath house orgies and Scientology "cures,". Now presenting John Travolta: A Portrait of the Actor as the Sum of His Gay Rumors. 1975: TV Breakthrough, Scientology Conversion Click to view Where His Dick Is: Submitting to its first Church of Scientology audits (essentially elaborate confessionals) as the actor converts to the religion from Catholicism.